BitTorrent + INDUCE Act + Linspire 5.0
Oren Beck
oren_beck at hotmail.com
Sun Oct 17 21:13:24 CDT 2004
Monty J. Harder wrote:
> "Leo Mauler" <webgiant at yahoo.com> wrote:
>
>
>>Uh oh, looks like we're going to have to start quoting
>>"Sissel's Law". :)
>>
>>Seriously, I don't think anyone will let us forget
>>Hitler. No matter how watered down the memory gets,
>>everyone will remember him, at least, as a Really Bad
>>Man Who Did Bad Things To People.
>
And thus Hitler became an archetype sometimes claimed
as so needful to make points in arguments we'd have to have
invented him were he not real .
> Here's Monster's Commentary on Mauler's Corollary to Sissel's Law:
>
> Hitler will always be remembered as the person to whom some people compare
> others, in order to make them seem bad. Unfortunately, by doing so, they
> usually end up making their intended target look pretty darned benign by
> comparison. Godwin's Law comes into play when people (including myself)
> make 'slippery slope' arguments:
My humble take is that Godwin's Law was a social patch for mail /news
readers
lacking a thread kill feature .
> A: The people have voted, and their will should be respected;
> <insert populist target here> must be ended now!
> B: The majority of Athenian citizens voted to condemn Socrates for
> his dangerous ideas. The majority thought the earth was flat, until
> Columbus and Magellan proved them wrong. The majority of the settlers that
> came to some of the colonies as a result, thought that slavery was OK, and
> when that was repealed, they supported Jim Crow after that. (Just to bring
> it on topic, a majority of desktop computer users run Windows, and
> apparently equate file sharing to terrorism.) And, by the way, Hitler was
> elected. I believe that certain things are wrong no matter how large the
> number of people willing to do them, and that no majority is large enough to
> validate them.
> A: You mentioned Hitler, so the thread's over and I win!
> B: No, because I don't believe in Godwin.
> A: Well, yo mama dresses you funny!
Yo mama ? wasn't he a violin player ?
Oren
www.campdownunder.com
More information about the Kclug
mailing list